Edit/delete posts & edit username whenever desired

Got a suggestion for the site, or got some feedback? Feel free to post it right here.
Post Reply
CarsonFireAlarm
Casual Participant
Casual Participant
Posts: 58
Joined: Tue Jan 28, 2014 8:50 am
YouTube Username: TheCarson116
Location: North Carolina, United States

Yeah, just what the title says. I don't know why post editing isn't a standard feature given how comment editing is standard on sites like Youtube, for one thing it allows you to correct errors in the post if necessary. As far as changing one's username, I believe I've been told that it IS possible, but I can't seem to find the button to do so anywhere. (therefore I'm not sure if I just need help as to where the "Edit Username" button is or that the ability to do so should be added) Another nice feature would be the ability to delete your posts if desired.
User avatar
The 4251-13
Casual Participant
Casual Participant
Posts: 37
Joined: Mon Jun 15, 2020 4:38 pm
YouTube Username: TheCrafter1952 Official
Location: La Crosse County, WI
Contact:

I'll second that.
-TC1952
My avatar says "Crafter" in the kana system, not "Fire."
"HAVE FUN STORMING THE CASTLE!" - Billy Crystal
Visit my YouTube (If it ever has content...)
I am on GeoFS - Look for my callsign: N1952TC
User avatar
randomperson
Serious Participant
Serious Participant
Posts: 551
Joined: Mon Jun 12, 2017 8:59 pm
YouTube Username: randomperson Fire Alarms
Location: Somewhere near Boston
Contact:

I third this, especially being able to delete posts.
This is especially important as some users might post information that their employer doesn’t want to be posted publicly.
Posting fire alarm systems from eastern Massachusetts (and a few other places) since 2017. he/him

YouTube | Twitter | Facebook
Email: everysingletrouble3 -AT- gmail -DOT- com
CarsonFireAlarm
Casual Participant
Casual Participant
Posts: 58
Joined: Tue Jan 28, 2014 8:50 am
YouTube Username: TheCarson116
Location: North Carolina, United States

I guess I should clarify that I made a mistake with my initial post (which I can't go back & edit due to the following reason): you CAN edit a post you just posted & for a couple minutes after, but for whatever reason eventually the edit button disappears & you can't edit it again. REALLY stupid in my opinion.
CarsonFireAlarm
Casual Participant
Casual Participant
Posts: 58
Joined: Tue Jan 28, 2014 8:50 am
YouTube Username: TheCarson116
Location: North Carolina, United States

So, are my suggestions going to be used? I don't know if the staff are going to use my ideas, heck I don't even know how they'd implement them. (unless it would be in a future site update, though I can't seem to recall any)
User avatar
Robert A
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 974
Joined: Sun May 26, 2013 11:13 pm
YouTube Username: Aslin Fire Safety
Location: Stillwater, OK
Contact:

Mod staff can definitely look into it, but if I recall correctly, those limitations are in place because of issues the old mod staff had in the past:

Editing/deleting posts used to be used to 'change the story' in the past. We had a user get into an argument with numerous members, as well as staff. He had been editing his posts to appear correct and in an effort to change his story. Staff then disabled the ability to edit posts that were not that user's last post, after a specified amount of time.

Changing one's username also used to be allowed by each member, but it came with the warning that it would be disabled if abused. Andrew also had mentioned linking TFP's username database with another site (the old Wiki), and eventually disabled username changes:
NewAgeServer wrote: Because of the Single Sign-On system set up between the wiki and the forum, we had to disable username changes because only the forum's username database is affected.

If you want your name changed, send an admin or website team member a PM saying you want your username changed, and with the new username, and it'll be taken care of.

We don't allow users to change their usernames because we're working on linking the user database with another site and name changes do not update easily.
Now that the wiki is no longer community-driven, we may look into allowing this again, but we'd still have the caveat that this would be disabled if abused. Similar to the Discord server, we prefer it if users changed their usernames sparingly. This way, we'd be able to keep track of everyone.
Robert Aslin | Moderator
My YouTube Channel | Aslin Fire Safety
If you need to contact me for any reason, please send me a PM, or email me at aslinrobert15(at)gmail.com
User avatar
randomperson
Serious Participant
Serious Participant
Posts: 551
Joined: Mon Jun 12, 2017 8:59 pm
YouTube Username: randomperson Fire Alarms
Location: Somewhere near Boston
Contact:

I understand the limitations around editing, but is it possible to allow deleting posts?
Posting fire alarm systems from eastern Massachusetts (and a few other places) since 2017. he/him

YouTube | Twitter | Facebook
Email: everysingletrouble3 -AT- gmail -DOT- com
User avatar
The 4251-13
Casual Participant
Casual Participant
Posts: 37
Joined: Mon Jun 15, 2020 4:38 pm
YouTube Username: TheCrafter1952 Official
Location: La Crosse County, WI
Contact:

So moved, and I'll second that.
I would also like to make a motion to allow users to edit all posts that are less than 2 weeks old, but moderators may:
a. Remove long-term editing privileges (e.g. revert to original editing rules) from a single user at a time.
b. Remove instant editing privileges (e.g. the edit has to be approved) from a single user at a time.
c. Restore the original post (e.g. original posts <= 𝑛 days old are stored and can be restored.)
-TC1952
My avatar says "Crafter" in the kana system, not "Fire."
"HAVE FUN STORMING THE CASTLE!" - Billy Crystal
Visit my YouTube (If it ever has content...)
I am on GeoFS - Look for my callsign: N1952TC
CarsonFireAlarm
Casual Participant
Casual Participant
Posts: 58
Joined: Tue Jan 28, 2014 8:50 am
YouTube Username: TheCarson116
Location: North Carolina, United States

Good idea 4251-13, why restrict it for ALL users when only some users, particularly those that are bad-behaved, should have editing (& other privileges) disabled. I'm mostly suggesting this just because I'd prefer a little more control over my own posts than what I have now. (along with of course being able to fix any errors if necessary)
Post Reply