Menards’ Interesting Smoke Alarm Selection

I’m pretty sure this is the best category for this. If you don’t think so and it bothers you, feel free to move it yourself or let me know.

For anyone who doesn’t know, Menards is a major chain of stores here in the Midwest that competes with Lowe’s and The Home Depot (although my area doesn’t have a Home Depot store). They also sell many other categories of products, including food, toys, decorations, and furniture. I go there quite a bit because they have significantly lower prices and a pretty good selection. The only reason I ever go to Lowe’s or somewhere else is if Menards doesn’t carry the specific item I’m looking for (which is very rare).

My local Menards store has always had a pretty interesting smoke alarm selection (so far, it’s the only place that I’ve ever bought smoke alarms from), but it has recently gotten pretty interesting. Menards has always partnered with Kidde to sell their products. Menards also rebranded some Kidde products under the “Smart Electrician” brand. Literally the only difference was the packaging and a slightly lower price. They have also always sold USI alarms (say what you want about that).

At that time, Menards also sold one Siterwell alarm rebranded by Smart Electrician. That alarm can actually be seen as the Photoelectric alarm in Technology Connections’ video about ionization vs photoelectric technology:

The “Kidde i9040” is also likely a “Smart Electrician i9040” since he probably got both units from Menards at the same time.

Recently, they have narrowed their Kidde selection to almost exclusively the “DETECT” line of products. They do still sell the same USI products. Now, they also seem to rebrand some other random smoke alarms under the “PERFORMAX” brand. They seem to be made by Siterwell as well. Now, the only ionization alarms that they sell are the USI ones.

Here’s what I’m talking about:

Most of them have 10 year sealed batteries. To me, the most intriguing alarm is the smoke and co combo alarm that can be battery powered or hardwired and can have wired or wireless interconnect. This would be a great “one size fits all” alarm that anyone could buy to install anywhere in their house and it will work as intended. If I was replacing all of my alarms, I would consider those as a good option to replace all of my existing alarms and add coverage to the lacking areas that do not have wiring for it.

If you want to see their full selection on their website, I made it easy for you:

If anyone’s a smoke alarm collector, these might be cool, less common additions to your collection.

1 Like

I’m all for collecting & preserving unique variants of devices such as detectors rebranded by retailers like Sears, JCPenney, Montgomery Ward, Canadian Tire, Menards, & others, but just the same I for one wouldn’t trust/rely on Siterwell (one “T”, not two, by the way) detectors for actual life safety considering Siterwell themselves are based in China (a country well-known for turning out cheaply-engineered garbage) & them likely having nowhere near the amount of experience in the life safety industry that veterans like BRK/First Alert do (the latter of which would be my first choice).

1 Like

Another instance of Menards having literally everything!

Everywhere with Kidde seems to have gone exclusively with the Detect and the 10-Year battery Kidde detector. You can’t even get FireX stuff anymore.

Yeah: stinks if you ask me.

The funny thing is that I could have sworn they stopped using the FireX brand name over a decade ago, yet only a few years back I found a Kidde FireX-branded detector for sale at a thrift store, & it was fairly new too! (forget the date of manufacture exactly but it was fairly new at the time)

Wow. And we got brand new FireX detectors at Walmart only a few years ago after our old ones died one by one in various ways!

I don’t know about other stores, but up until they switched to the DETECT line a lot of the Kidde alarms at Menards were sold in FireX branded boxes.

The reason that China seems like it turns out garbage, well, is because it is the largest country that makes stuff in the world.
Good things are made in China, those first alert smoke alarms are made there.

My i9050 came in a FireX box, and it’s from October 8 2022, and the package had a copyright date of 2020-22?

Yeah, but as we’ve seen time & again that doesn’t make them the best now does it?

Yes, I’m sure China does make some good-quality things, but also no: Kidde is the one with a factory in China, whereas BRK/First Alert has a plant in Mexico instead (& if you ask me “Made in Mexico” (or “Hecho en Mexico” as they often say there) is a lot better (& has got to be better) than “Made in China”).

As I found out the other week Kidde does very much still use the FireX brand despite me thinking that they had long since gotten it out of the way in favor of their own name, so yours makes sense (didn’t think they still sold the i9050 either though).